The migration that goes wrong is almost never the slow one — it's the rushed one. The team that exports on Friday, cancels on Monday, and spends the next month reconstructing records from memory. There's no reason to do it that way. Thirty days is a comfortable pace, your old system stays live the whole time, and there is no point in the plan below where you're standing at the edge of a cliff.
A word on framing before we start: Shelterluv is a capable, well-designed platform, and this isn't a post about whether you should leave it. If you're still weighing that decision, our Shelterluv alternative page covers the trade-offs honestly — including when staying is the right call — and our breakdown of Shelterluv's pricing covers the cost side. This guide is for teams that have already decided to move, or want to know exactly what moving would take before deciding. And while the Pet Friend specifics are noted where they apply, most of this plan works no matter which platform you're moving to.
One rule above all: pick a quiet month, not peak intake season. A migration during kitten season is how careful plans become war stories.
Week 1 — Export and audit
The first week is about getting everything out of Shelterluv while you have full, paid access — and writing down what "everything" is, so you can prove later that nothing was lost. Don't touch the new system yet. This week is entirely about your own data.
- Pull your exports. Start with the AnimalInventory export — it's the backbone of the migration — then grab the other reports you rely on. Our step-by-step guide to exporting your data from Shelterluv walks through exactly where each one lives. Do this now, not in week 4: exports are easiest while your account is fully active.
- Record your baseline counts. Animals currently in care, year-to-date adoptions, year-to-date intakes, active fosters. Write them down somewhere outside either system — a shared doc is fine. These numbers are how you'll verify the import in week 2, and the final archive in week 4.
- List your integrations and must-keep workflows. Petfinder and Adopt-a-Pet syncing, microchip registration, payment processing, website embeds, the adoption contract your board approved, the cage card your kennel staff actually read. If it would hurt to lose, it goes on the list.
- Name one migration owner. One person — not a committee — who holds the checklist, makes the small calls, and knows the state of the migration at any moment. Everything that goes sideways in migrations goes sideways in the gap between two people who each thought the other one did it.
By the end of week 1 you should have your exports saved in two places, your baseline counts written down, and a one-page list of everything the new system has to do before you can leave the old one.
Week 2 — Import and verify
Now the data moves. How much work this week involves depends heavily on the platform you're moving to, so ask your new vendor exactly what their import handles — and what it silently drops.
- Import your data. With Pet Friend, you upload the AnimalInventory export and the format is detected and mapped automatically — animals, statuses, microchips, intake history, and active foster placements — with a full preview before anything is created. If you'd rather hand the whole thing off, white-glove migration is free: send us the export, we do the import, and we verify the counts with you.
- Verify against your week 1 numbers. Animals in care should match. Active fosters should match. If the new system's counts don't reconcile with the numbers you wrote down, stop and find out why before doing anything else. This is the single most important checkpoint in the whole plan.
- Spot-check 10–20 animals end to end. Pick a mix — a long-stay dog with a thick medical file, a kitten that arrived last week, an animal in foster, one that was returned and re-adopted. Open each record and check that the story reads correctly: intake date, status, microchip, medical history. Totals can match while details are wrong; spot checks catch what counts can't.
- Rebuild the forms and printouts you actually use. Not all of them — the handful from your week 1 list. Adoption contract, cage card, intake form. Most teams discover they were carrying a dozen forms and using three.
Week 3 — Parallel run and training
This is the week the migration becomes real for everyone who isn't the migration owner. The data is in; now the people move.
- Run both systems in parallel — with one written rule. Either enter new intakes in both systems, or adopt the simpler rule: everything new goes in the new system, history stays in the old one. Both approaches work. What doesn't work is ambiguity — pick one rule, write it where everyone can see it, and hold to it. Split-brain data, where nobody is sure which system is right, is the failure mode this week exists to prevent.
- Train on the daily workflows, not the whole product. Intake, adoption with e-signature, and medical entries cover the large majority of what staff and volunteers touch. Get those three fluent first; the rest can be learned on demand.
- Keep a running "how do I…" list. Every question anyone asks goes on the list, along with the answer once it's found. By go-live it becomes your in-house quick-reference — and any question that doesn't have an answer yet is a flag that something from your week 1 list isn't rebuilt.
- Verify Petfinder before you touch the old sync. Confirm your adoptable listings are publishing correctly from the new system before turning off the old one. Do it in that order and you avoid the classic mistake: duplicate listings if both sync at once, or vanished listings if you switch off the old sync before the new one is confirmed.
If your organization is coming from paper or spreadsheets alongside Shelterluv, the training approach in our switching from paper to digital guide applies here too: short sessions, real records, and one workflow at a time.
Week 4 — Go-live and wind-down
By now the new system has real data, the team has real reps, and the parallel run has surfaced the surprises. Week 4 is about ending cleanly.
- Pick the cut-over day. A specific date, announced in advance. Early in the week is better than a Friday — you want a few working days of full attention after the switch, not a weekend.
- Stop entering data in the old system. From the cut-over day forward, the new system is the system of record. The parallel-run rule ends; there is now exactly one place to look.
- Keep read-only access to the old system if you can. Access typically continues through the end of your current billing period — check your account terms so you know exactly how long you have. A few weeks of being able to look something up in the old system is a cheap safety net.
- Export a final archive. One last export from Shelterluv covering everything through the cut-over date, including anything entered during the parallel run. This is your permanent record of the old system's final state.
- Update your website embeds and links. Adoption application forms, adoptable-pet embeds, donation links — anything on your website that points at the old system.
- Tell your partners. Your vet clinics, transfer partners, and any coalition or municipal reporting contacts — anyone who receives records or reports from you should know the format may look different starting this month.
After the switch
The migration isn't finished on go-live day; it's finished when the first normal month has gone through the new system without drama.
- Watch the first month's reports. Run your usual monthly numbers — intakes, outcomes, animals in care — and sanity-check them against what a normal month looks like. Reporting is where subtle data issues surface, and the first month is when they're cheapest to fix.
- Cancel the old subscription only after the final archive is verified. Open the archive, confirm it's complete and readable, and check it against your recorded counts. Then cancel. Never the other way around.
- Keep the archive somewhere safe. Two places — cloud storage plus a local copy is the usual pattern. Adoption records have a way of being needed years later.
Switching from Shelterluv FAQ
How long does switching from Shelterluv really take?
The data import itself is usually the fast part — often a day or less. The 30 days in this plan is mostly for the human side: verifying the data, training staff and volunteers, and running in parallel long enough to catch surprises. You can compress the calendar if you need to, but the parallel-run week is the one worth protecting.
Do we lose our historical data when we leave Shelterluv?
Not if you export before you cancel. Pull your AnimalInventory export and other reports while your account is fully active, and take a final archive at cut-over. With Pet Friend, the AnimalInventory export brings across animals, statuses, microchips, intake history, and active fosters — and the final archive from your old system is your permanent backstop for anything beyond that.
Should we run both systems in parallel?
Yes, for a week or two. Either enter new records in both systems or route everything new to the new system while history stays in the old one — the important thing is picking one written rule so nobody is ever unsure which system is correct. Parallel running is what makes the whole migration low-risk: at no point are you without a working system.
When should we NOT switch?
Don't migrate during your busiest intake season — pick a quiet month. And if your team is happy on Shelterluv, uses it well, and the pricing model isn't a pain point, staying may genuinely be the right call. We lay out the honest case for staying as well as switching on our Shelterluv alternative page.
What does migration help cost?
With Pet Friend, nothing — white-glove migration is free. Send us your Shelterluv export, we handle the import, and we verify the counts with you while you keep access to your old system. Some vendors charge for migration assistance, so if you're evaluating other platforms, ask before you commit.
Want the plan priced for your organization?
Tell us your animal counts and plan needs and we'll send a written quote — or try the free interactive demo first, no signup needed.
Get a migration quote Try the Free Demo